Best Vegetarian Cook Book

Review by bensmomma:

I just counted 34 cookbooks in my kitchen, but this is the one I use the most. Only the Joy of Cooking gets an equal workout. This book is the only vegetarian cookbook I’ve ever seen that:1) Is comprehensive enough to cover every ingredient you have in your fridge (if you have a head of fennel and a potato, and nothing else, you will probably be able to find a recipe);2) Is neither too far in the “twigs pebbles and roughage” camp nor the “80 ingredients you never heard of and 3 hours you don’t have” camp. Most recipes are reasonable in scope and actually flavorful, although if you want to create a fancy banquet you can.Even if you are not a committed vegetarian (I’m not), but you just want to eat healthier, or to avoid the “vegetables turning into science experiments in the fridge” thing, this is a tremendous great resource.

Review by S. Gardner:

This has become my favorite cookbook. I have been vegetarian for nearly 20 years and I am an avid cook, and this book has provided nothing but perfect food, without meat, every time I have used it. I love good food. Food that is merely nutritious and not really good, also, is a bane to humanity. This food is not generally low-fat, but it is still whole, nutritious food. The desserts are great, the salads are great, the vegetable dishes are great. You name it, in this book, it’s good.The other thing that I love about this book is that Deborah Madison is not only a great chef she also knows how to translate her cooking talent into recipes that really WORK. I am disappointed by some chefs’ cookbooks because it’s obvious that they are excellent cooks, but their recipe-writing skills are sub-par. These, on the other hand, are well-tested, well-written recipes.The food in this book is what I’d call fine food. Some recipes in other cookbooks are for everyday-type food that will get you by, and others are for trendy food that are novel to make once in a while. The recipes in this book direct you to make the kind of food that will have you talking the next day about how good it was, and they’re not trendy. Most are also uncomplicated. The flavors are refined and you might call them sophisticated, but that’s misleading because there’s nothing pretentious about the recipes or the presentation. The sophistication comes from a cleanness to the palate that is presented here.I have a large collection of cookbooks (200+) and this one definitely stands out. If you have others of Madison’s cookbooks, such as the Savory Way or the Greens Cookbook, which are also both excellent, I suspect that you will find this one more accessible. There’s a hint of preciousness in those other two books that I find lacking here. Madison seems less concerned about impressing us in this book and more relaxed in her approach. This has improved her style and has improved her food, as well.

Review by Denise Patterson:

Let me start by saying I’m a busy working mom of two. I grew up eating Hamburger Helper and hot dogs, so I didn’t learn to cook until I was an adult. My dad’s had triple bypass and my mom’s having gastric bypass, so we’re trying to learn from their mistakes and eat not entirely vegetarian, but definitely a more plant-based diet. I’m sure all this sounds familiar to a lot of people!

How to Cook Everything Vegetarian is exactly the cookbook I’ve been trying to find for a long time. It has the simple, everyday recipes that I sometimes need, combined with a LOT of wonderful vegetarian dishes from ordinary supermarket ingredients. How about Peanut Soup, Senegalese Style? Or Korean-Style Noodles in Cool Bean Broth (in less than 20 minutes for when the kids are whining for dinner) Mustard Cheese Fondue?

This book is written in Bittman’s typical `theme and variations’ style, with a basic recipe (like for waffles) and then a sidebar or list following the recipe that gives variations (like a list of things you can add to waffles for flavoring). The great thing about this is that it means you rarely have to reject a recipe because you don’t have the exact ingredients, just go with a variant. The only quibble I have with it is, it’s sometimes difficult to keep track of what you are supposed to sub out & sub back in when you have a crying toddler on your ankle.

A basic cookbook should also walk you through basic techniques and ingredients. I was a little surprised to see the vegetables chapter was nearly 200 pages. Then I looked through it and realized a lot of that is guidance on how to select and prep the various vegetables. It’s also helpful that he includes substitution suggestions – I may be out of broccoli, but if I can make the same recipe with green beans, then I can forgo the trip to the store one more day.

Another nice thing about this cookbook is, unlike most vegetarian cookbooks I have seen, it doesn’t rely heavily on unusual ingredients or meat substitutes. It seems like there has to be a happy medium between burgers & fries on one hand and stuff you’ve never seen before. Surely we can make a healthy diet based on basic veggies, fruit, grains, and legumes, and that’s JUST what this book focuses on.

But it doesn’t matter how great the book is if the recipes aren’t good! So I tried a few. The Spicy Autumn Veggie Burgers (we made less spicy for the kids) were terrific with a dollop of peach chutney, although the kids preferred ketchup. I was pleased at how quickly they came together too. The Glazed Carrot Soup the kids ate without any complaint at all. And oh my the Apple “Fries”!!!!

Because I’m sure people are wondering – yes, he has another cookbook called How to Cook Everything: Vegetarian that came out several years ago. This is NOT just a remake of that slim volume. This is a completely new book. (Why his publishers wanted to do two books with titles the same except for a colon I’ll never know.) There’s no exact overlap with How to Cook Everything, that I saw – even for recipes like Waldorf Salad, that are essentially the same in both books, there is some slight variation and different text that shows that this was re-written, not just a cut-and-paste job.

In short, I’m very happy with it. I’ve cooked out of it every day since I got it and I’m sure this will be one of my `go-to’ cookbooks for years to come.

Review by Cookin’ up a storm:

I’m a vegetarian of 15 years (with a meat-eating but open minded fiance) and an avid home cook. I got this book for Christmas and have slowly been exploring it. It’s an interesting book and there are a lot of recipes that I’m tempted by, but it’s the same problem I have with “How to cook everything”: something is always wrong with the recipe. For example, his kosher pickles: the first time I tried making them with his measurements, the pickles were inedibly salty (and I love salt!) I’m now working with about a third less salt than he recommends and it’s getting better. And that’s what I always find with his recipes: they give you a promising start but require some major tinkering before they are really good, and I don’t usually feel up to committing to that sort of trial and error. I am a passionate fan of Debbie Madison’s “Vegetarian Cooking for Everyone.” As an example of the difference, this week I had a dinner party and I made her cauliflower salad with green olives and capers even though I’d never tried it before, and it was a hit. Having used her book so much, I trust her recipes to be at least decent right out of the gate. I would never serve a Bittman recipe that I hadn’t made before to guests because there are pretty good odds that the initial recipe needs some changes.

That being said, I’m certainly not sorry that I have this book. It has a good section on condiments that I’m sure I’ll make use of fairly often, and it’s a good cookbook to have on hand if you’re tinkering in the kitchen and want some perspective on your technique. It’s really more of a reference book than an book of recipes, and in that it is useful. But if you want ideas for delicious, satisfying vegetarian food, get “Vegetarian Cooking for Everyone.”